Original Brooklyn Pie Co.

Nestled in the heart of Round Rock, TX, Original Brooklyn Pie Co. serves up an authentic taste of New York-style pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of Brooklyn. This cozy pizza spot specializes in thin-crust pies that strike the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, creating a mouthwatering canvas for their rich, flavorful toppings.

The menu is a celebration of bold, crafted flavors. The Mona Lisa Chicken is a standout, combining tender chicken with savory mushrooms, smoky bacon, fresh spinach, and creamy gorgonzola, resulting in a sophisticated medley that lingers deliciously on the palate. If you’re drawn to familiar comfort, the Meat Lovers pie delivers a generous helping of pepperoni, ham, bacon, and sausage, each bite bursting with hearty, meaty goodness. For those craving a classic touch, the Margherita enchants with its delicate brush of olive oil and garlic sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella, ripe Roma tomatoes, and fragrant basil – simple ingredients elevated to perfection. Not to be missed, the White Castle Cheeseburger pizza offers a playful twist, combining hamburger, red onions, crispy bacon, and sharp cheddar for a flavor-packed experience.

Beyond pizzas, their calzones are equally exceptional. The Meat Calzone, stuffed with sausage, pepperoni, and a luscious blend of ricotta and mozzarella, arrives piping hot with a side of zesty marinara sauce, inviting you to savor every warm, cheesy bite. The Veggie Calzone offers a garden-fresh alternative, loaded with bell peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, ricotta, and mozzarella—perfectly balanced and satisfying.

The atmosphere at Original Brooklyn Pie Co. reflects its NY roots with an authentic Italian pizzeria vibe, small yet vibrant. Inside, the space is intimate and warmly decorated, reminiscent of a quirky Brooklyn slice shop, giving the experience a genuine local feel. While seating is limited, the friendly buzz and outdoor dining area provide a relaxed setting to enjoy your meal. Be sure to come prepared for a no-frills drink selection that pairs well with their hearty pies—from classic Mexican Coke crafted with pure cane sugar to refreshing Powerade and flavorful sodas in convenient bottles.

Customer reviews paint a lively picture: Mike Crane raves about their in-house made meat calzones, describing them as generously loaded with savory meats and cheese, perfectly complemented by marinara. Julie Catalan calls the giant slice “amazing,” praising its satisfying crispiness and ideal thin crust that’s become their go-to. Though some feedback notes the limited seating and occasionally brisk service, the overwhelming sentiment appreciates the authentic flavors and culinary pride that makes this pizzeria a standout in the area.

For those who crave a true, no-compromise New York pizza experience without leaving Central Texas, Original Brooklyn Pie Co. offers a flavorful escape that delights the senses and honors the traditions of Brooklyn’s beloved pie culture. Whether grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a loaded specialty calzone, the passion for quality and bold taste shines through every bite.